Facebook whingers

Facebook logo Español: Logotipo de Facebook Fr...

Loving all the people who don’t like the new facebook “we can use your posts, comments and images in adverts” policies being touted, and who think that simply posting that “I do not give you permission…” etc. is enough to prevent this.

Sorry folks, by using facebook (for free, remember) you agree to *their* terms and conditions. If you don’t agree to them, then you can’t use the service. It’s not an “agreement” in that you sit down over a pint and discuss one-to-one how you’re going to use the service (for free) and then walk off after a handshake.

Facebook provide you with a contract to which you must agree to use their service. Part of that contract is that they are permitted to *change* that contract as long as they give fair notice (they seem to think 7 days is fair). If you don’t agree to the contract (in whole or in part), you don’t use the service. That’s the agreement.

Frankly, I think it’s a storm in a teacup. The example of usage they’ve mentioned is, for instance, an advert for a venue underneath which they may place a post from one of your friends who’s been there before. A post/picture you’ll already have seen as you’re on their friends list. They aren’t taking stuff you’ve posted to a limited audience (friends, groups…) and posting them publicly.

Get over it, or get out. Good luck gaining as large an audience or following on Google+ with its echoing walls.

Enhanced by Zemanta

3 thoughts on “Facebook whingers”

  1. EXCEPT… it’s not a negotiated contract, and you have no chance to amend it, like that guy in Russia did with his phone contract. You hold copyright to your own work, and nobody gets to license your work just because THEY say so. You are free to add your own non-negotiated shrinkwrap terms and conditions to stuff you hold the copyright to, all you like. That’s exactly how shrinkwrap agreements work. Anyone can do them. Including you. Or me.

    By quoting this comment you agree to pay a license fee of one pint of fine perry per year for the duration of its display.

    Thing is, the onus to get you to accept that you are bound by that, and to actually force you to pay up, is now on me. It would cost me MANY fine glasses of perry in legal fees to even stand a chance.

  2. Hence my “if you don’t like it, go elsewhere” comment. You could argue that the license agreement for purchasing MS Office is not negotiated. You buy it and to install it, you have to agree to 17 pages of tiny text that you don’t read. Amongst these is that you will only install it on two machines, one of which is portable and you will only use it on one machine at a time.

    But I would like to run it on four desktops. So can I ring MS and negotiate because I paid for it and therefore I have a right to do so? Technically I could try. Would they agree? Erm, no. Similarly, you’ve every right to post “I do not give fb permission to…” on your timeline. This does not mean you’ve opted out of the contract you read (cough) and agreed to when you signed up.

    You’re right, it’s not negotiated. It’s a choice. Sign up and agree, or don’t sign up and don’t complain.

    Oh, and you’re wrong on the copyright thing I’m afraid. If you’re employed by the council in Scotland (teachers are the example I’m aware of, but I gather it can affect other branches) and you publish a text – any text – while employed by them or within a certain length of time afterwards, they as your employers own the copyright. Even if you worked on it “out of hours”. I always wanted to test this one out by writing some hard core brutal fetish porn and getting it published to see if they’d decide they wanted to claim ownership, but didn’t get round to it…

    It’s in the contract. You agree to it when you sign up to work for them. It’s non-negotiable.

    P.S. I’ve not quoted your comment, though the blogging software did publish it. Therefore I don’t own you any fermented pear juice. Hell, I could have refused to approve it and nobody would have seen it 😉

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *